Charles E. Baker State Forest provides primitive camping on dirt roads approximately 30 minutes from Hartwick, New York. The area features several undesignated campsites alongside designated sites across multiple state forests in the region. The elevation varies between 1,500-1,800 feet with summer temperatures averaging 65-75°F during camping season.
What to do
Fishing at stocked ponds: Many dispersed campsites connect to fishing opportunities, particularly for brook trout. At Pharsalia Y Pond, the water is "deep and clear and stocked with brook trout, and the campsite on the east side of the pond is in an idyllic setting with good camping, fishing (canoe or kayak only), and day hikes."
Hiking trail connections: Access the Finger Lakes Trail directly from several campsites. The Pharsalia Woods Lean-To Campsite is "beautifully maintained primitive group campsite with large Adirondack style lean-to, several picnic tables and fire rings, and firewood provided. Maintained by volunteers of the local Bullthistle Hikers Club."
Paddling small ponds: Many sites allow direct water access for small watercraft. One camper at Duck Pond Campsite noted "the pond is small so the mosquitos were not too bad. So few people passed by and very unknown quite and we just loved the experience."
Winter cross-country skiing: Betty and Wilbur Davis State Park cabins support winter recreation. According to a visitor, you can "come for a long weekend of cozy cabin time and quiet time outdoors on the winter trails."
What campers like
Natural settings with privacy: Most dispersed sites provide substantial separation between campers. At Bear Wallow Pond Dispersed Campsite, one reviewer noted it's "a primitive undeveloped campsite, there is a clearing for tenting but no potable water or amenities of any kind. The site is adjacent to a small parking area and fishing access on a really beautiful pond."
Simple amenities at some sites: A few locations offer basic facilities. At Charles E. Baker State Forest, a camper found "a fire pit and picnic table. Some litter, not too bad. No toilets. Bugs aren't an issue. Water access at a lovely nearby pond."
Cost-effective options: Many sites have no fees, making them budget-friendly for overnight stays. One camper reported of Charles E. Baker State Forest: "Beautiful forest with miles of trails. I found this spot passing through on my bike and had no problem pitching a tent in a secluded spot in the woods."
Wildlife viewing: The state forests host abundant bird species and other wildlife. Pharsalia Y Pond provides good opportunities where "you can also walk or drive along various state forest roads to several other ponds in the Wildlife Management area for good birdwatching."
What you should know
Road conditions vary: Access to remote sites can be challenging for standard vehicles. At Duck Pond Campsite, a visitor warned: "The road in on old cemetery rd was pretty rough, so we decided to go out the other way, which was way worse... Intermittent cell service which was frightening while driving on these rough roads."
Permit requirements for some areas: Wildlife Management Areas typically require advance permits. For Pharsalia Y Pond, "Camping in this DEC Wildlife Management Area campsite is limited, and requires a permit. Visit the regional DEC office at 1285 Fisher Ave., Cortland NY or call 607-753-3095... allow one week for permit to be processed."
Limited stays at canal sites: The Erie Canal provides camping with specific restrictions. At E16 Canal Lock, "Stays are limited to a maximum of 48 hours. Upon arrival, campers must scan the QR code at the entrance and complete a brief survey."
Water treatment necessary: Most primitive sites lack potable water sources. A visitor to Pharsalia Woods Lean-To noted "There is a perennial spring nearby, but campers should be prepared to filter or treat their water."
Tips for camping with families
Cabin options for beginners: Families new to camping may prefer the comfort of cabins. Betty and Wilbur Davis State Park offers "camper cabins—and pretty amazing glamping for camper cabins! Although there may be times when there may be people and groups around for day use, the small number of cabins and they way they are spread out will make you feel like you are at your own private retreat."
Playground access: Some parks offer recreation facilities for children. Betty and Wilbur Davis State Park has "a beautiful picnic pavilion and playground, so kid friendly."
Cell service reliability: Plan activities considering limited connectivity. At Duck Pond Campsite, visitors experienced "Intermittent cell service which was frightening while driving on these rough roads."
Multiple water activities: Coordinate fishing and paddling at appropriate locations. Regarding Pharsalia Y Pond, a camper stated it "would be a nice family friendly weekend destination, as well as a great stop for through hikers."
Tips from RVers
Size restrictions for access: Large RVs and trailers cannot access most dispersed sites. At E16 Canal Lock, "RVs and travel trailers are not permitted."
Better cell coverage at established sites: More developed campgrounds offer consistent connectivity. At E16 Canal Lock, "The Verizon signal is good in the area."
Small campervans only: Some rough access roads can accommodate smaller campervans. One reviewer at Duck Pond Campsite suggested "Small vehicle only" access due to rough road conditions.