Cabin accommodations near New Milford provide options across the New Jersey-New York border region, nestled in the Skylands area where elevations range from 400-1,800 feet. Winter temperatures often drop below freezing from December through February, requiring cabin campers to prepare for potentially icy conditions. Most cabins in this region remain open year-round but require reservations several months in advance.
What to Do
Fishing opportunities: Lake Ocquittunk in Stokes State Forest offers accessible shoreline fishing. "We stayed at the campsite at Lake Ocquittunk Area... We didn't have direct views of the lake, but were within a minute walk to some quiet views of the lake," notes a visitor who rated the experience highly.
Hiking trails: Mahlon Dickerson Reservation provides access to multiple trail systems. According to one camper, "We always hike to the lake here, it's a very easy hike and also very peaceful." Another notes you should "Make sure to visit Headley overlook and hike the awesome trials that surround the campsites!"
Water activities: Neversink River Resort offers tubing experiences on the Neversink River. "Tubing was fun. Bring bug spray," advises one visitor, while others mention bringing personal rafts and tubes to float on the river.
Animal encounters: Pleasant Acres Farm includes farm animals that interact with guests. A reviewer mentions, "My daughter loved the horses and goats," while another notes the campground has "goats, a donkey, and a pony within the campground."
What Campers Like
Privacy levels: Mahlon Dickerson Reservation receives praise for its secluded settings. "The campground is small but also secluded," writes one reviewer. Another notes, "Our site is easily the nicest- all the way in the back with only one neighbor. It is so quiet here."
Tent platforms: Many cabin camping areas provide wooden platforms for tents. One Mahlon Dickerson visitor explains, "At the campgrounds there is a platform where you can pitch your tent," while another notes, "They have these 12x12 platforms to put your tent on. This was pretty cool especially since some of the sites are all gravel with surrounding dirt."
Scenic views: Moon Valley Campground offers unique landscape vistas. A camper describes it as "nestled in the foothills of Northern NJ on the NY border. Small, clean with great views and great location for hiking, cruising etc." Another mentions returning for "a fall weekend in the 'dome' which has incredible views."
Communal activities: Sebago Cabin Camp organizes regular social events. "Sebago has a ton of activities like outdoor movies and communal bonfires on weekends. I was told by ranger Joe they also do Karaoke nights too," shares one visitor.
What You Should Know
Bathroom facilities: Standards vary significantly between campgrounds. At High Point State Park Campground, "Bathrooms are spaced out. No running water except for pump founded outside of the bathrooms. Toilets are pump flushed. Showers are only located INSIDE High Point State Park, not throughout the campsites."
Cabin simplicity: Sebago cabins offer minimal amenities. "These cabins are VERY rustic, four walls, a cot, and a fridge. You still feel like you are 'roughing it' but with the convenience of a fridge," explains a reviewer who appreciated the balance.
Seasonal considerations: Most cabins have limited insulation. One Stokes State Forest visitor mentions, "The cabins are reasonably priced and well-appointed, if a bit rustic...You need that wood stove to heat up the cabin. Turning on the oven is a help, but not a good solution."
Cell service: Coverage is limited in many locations. A Sebago camper reports, "Absolutely zero phone service (for T-Mobile) which was AMAZING," showing how disconnection can be viewed positively.
Tips for Camping with Families
Family-friendly activities: AMC Harriman Outdoor Center provides structured experiences. "Great camping for all abilities. Free camping at stone shelters. Beautiful lakes all over the place," reports one visitor, while another praises their "meal plan (Option for breakfast, lunch, dinner) that you can get at their dinning hall and I HIGHLY recommend that option."
Playground options: Campgrounds offer varying play structures. At Kittatinny Campground, "There is a bounce pillow to jump on and a really old and rickity swing set and an old metal slide. also, there's a pool," though some note facilities need updating.
Animal encounters: Pleasant Acres Farm provides animal interactions. Visitors mention "plenty to occupy the kids. Playground, hayride, animals to feed (goats, chickens, donkey and pony)," making it popular for family stays.
Noise considerations: Some areas have variable noise levels. A Kittatinny visitor notes, "If your looking for a chill place to camp next to the river where you can tube, kayak and enjoy your peaceful weekend, this is NOT the place," as it's more suitable for groups seeking a livelier atmosphere.
Tips from RVers
Site selection: At Mahlon Dickerson, "The campsites are paved and mostly level. They are wooded and large. Water and electric hookups and a dump station," but some reviewers note certain sites require leveling adjustments.
Hookup details: Various campgrounds offer different utility options. Mahlon Dickerson provides "electric and water hookups for your RV which is great!" while a reviewer mentions, "Website lists water hook ups at long distances but they have hose reels to help with that."
Accessibility: Navigation can be challenging at some campgrounds. A Pleasant Acres Farm reviewer cautions, "When you leave you have to drive the wrong way in the campground because of the low hanging trees the correct direction."
Seasonal availability: Many cabin facilities operate with limited winter schedules. Most close from November through March, though Pleasant Acres Farm RV Resort provides "year-round cabin rentals with full hookups in a farm setting."
