Primitive camping near Thiells, New York concentrates in state-managed forested lands within Rockland County and adjacent regions. The area sits at modest elevations ranging from 400-800 feet with deciduous forest dominating the landscape. Seasonal factors heavily impact these undeveloped sites, with fall offering reduced insect activity while spring brings muddy conditions requiring appropriate footwear and waterproof gear.
What to do
Hiking from camp: Taconic Hereford Multiple Use Park offers extensive trail networks across its 900+ acres that connect to additional protected forest land. A visitor noted, "There is plenty of trails to explore and wildlife to enjoy, especially since these over 900 acres also back up to another huge plot of protected forests."
Rock climbing access: Hemlock Ridge MUA serves primarily as a basecamp for climbers heading to nearby formations. One camper mentioned, "Many climbers stay there for access to the gunks," highlighting the practical nature of this location for outdoor sport enthusiasts.
Lakeside activities: Hickok Brook provides opportunities for fishing and paddling with primitive tent sites positioned near the water. Visitors should note the limited vehicle access beyond certain points, as one camper explained, "No motor vehicles beyond where I'm camping. Bring everything with you."
What campers like
Solitude and seclusion: At Hemlock Ridge MUA, the isolation appeals to those seeking quiet primitive camping. One reviewer shared, "There are absolutely no amenities whatsoever & barely even a signal here, but it's quiet & off the beaten path."
Convenience with wilderness feel: Taconic Hereford Multiple Use Park offers a wilderness experience with unexpected conveniences. A camper noted, "This spot is easy to find and access, and had decent ATT service," which provides reassurance for those wanting both seclusion and connectivity.
Waterfront sites: The lakeside locations at Hickok Brook attract campers despite challenges. "Had to move next to the lake. Need a permit on NY state land. Contact Rangers office of whatever county," advised one visitor, highlighting both the appeal of waterfront camping and the permit requirements.
What you should know
Limited parking capacity: Most dispersed areas feature extremely small parking areas that fill quickly, especially on weekends. At Hemlock Ridge MUA, a camper observed, "The parking lot only holds about 4-5 cars, 6 if you park real tight."
Difficult access roads: Roads to primitive sites often require appropriate vehicles. A camper at Hickok Brook warned, "The road is very rough with huge potholes so good clearance is a must. It's not a good spot for car camping."
Permit requirements: Taconic Hereford Multiple Use Park and other state lands often require permits for overnight stays. A visitor to Hickok Brook learned this firsthand: "Where I originally camped was not a spot, according to Ranger. Need a permit on NY state land."
Tips for camping with families
Pack in all necessities: No facilities exist at these sites, requiring complete self-sufficiency. A visitor to Hickok Brook advised, "Bring everything with you. It's a hike back to town... there is a small town 10 minutes away. Eldred, NY."
Manage bug exposure: Insect protection is essential during warmer months. A camper at Hemlock Ridge warned, "Bugs are relentless," suggesting families bring appropriate repellent and protective clothing.
Choose accessible spots: For families, sites closer to parking areas reduce hiking distance with gear. At Hemlock Ridge MUA, a camper noted, "I only seen/stayed at one camping spot which is literally at about the required 150ft from the road," indicating options exist that minimize hiking with children and equipment.
Tips from RVers
Size restrictions: These primitive sites generally cannot accommodate recreational vehicles of any significant size. A visitor to Hickok Brook explained, "I drove in thinking that there would be flat places to park a very rugged camper in my full ton diesel pickup. The road is very rough with huge potholes... Very gorgeous but not RV friendly."
Limited turnaround space: Many forest roads lack adequate space for larger vehicles to maneuver. A camper at Taconic Hereford Multiple Use Park cautioned, "the road is narrow with not much turnaround room, I wouldn't recommend for trailers or RVs."