The western Adirondack foothills around Croghan, New York offer primitive camping experiences with varying levels of remoteness. Summer temperatures typically range from 55-78°F, while spring and fall can see overnight temperatures drop below 40°F. The region's mixed hardwood forests provide shade for tent campers during summer months, with many sites situated near water bodies that moderate temperatures.
What to do
Paddling access: Several campsites at Alger Island Adirondack Preserve require boat transportation. "To get to the campground, you must paddle. The state park allows only car top boats. We kayaked all of our gear out to the island," notes Sarah B., who adds that holiday periods bring increased boat traffic on the surrounding lake.
Winter recreation: The Winona Forest area transforms into a snow sports destination during winter months. One camper at Winona Forest CCC Camp reports, "This is a hub for several snow mobile, cross country ski, and snow shoe trails. Several folks visited on Saturday and Sunday to enjoy the last bit of the snow."
Swimming spots: Natural swimming areas provide relief during summer months. The Salmon River near Hall Island State Forest offers swimming holes and jumping spots. One camper notes, "The draw for my friends and I at the time was a jump off the nearby Redfield bridge and swim in the Salmon River."
What campers like
Island seclusion: Tioga Point Campground offers boat-in only access that creates a more private experience. "The campground is very secluded and there are lean-to style campsites. You don't have to bring a tent unless you want to. This definitely saves some space in your boat," reports Carrie J.
Natural gathering spaces: Some primitive sites feature natural community areas. At Seventh Lake Primitive Camping, "There is a large sand bar within a very short walk which was a great place to hang out," according to Mary B., who accessed the site by canoe.
Morning views: Waterfront sites provide memorable wake-up scenes. At North Lake Reservoir Campground, one camper arrived after dark and reports it was "beautiful to wake up to the view of the lake. Car camped, but there was enough room for a tent."
What you should know
Site identification challenges: Finding primitive sites can require careful attention. At Winona State Forest, "The primitive campsite was a little difficult to find there's a tiny black and yellow placard that shows you where you can camp," notes Thomas E. Similarly, boat-accessed sites can be hard to spot from the water.
Weather preparedness: Campers report variable conditions that can impact site quality. Kevin C. stayed at Winona State Forest during rain and noted, "It rained while we were here but overall the campsite was quiet and peaceful."
Site limitations: Most dispersed sites accommodate small groups only. Francis Lake offers "room for two or three tents, two fire circles and has an outhouse," according to visitor feedback.
Tips for camping with families
Water safety planning: Lakes and reservoirs present both recreation opportunities and safety concerns. At Adirondack Mennonite Camping Associates Inc, Elizabeth B. notes the site offers "swimming, canoes, and a high ropes course," but parental supervision remains essential at primitive water-access sites.
Wildlife awareness: Local wildlife includes black bears that frequent camping areas. One long-time visitor to Tioga Point advises, "Watch out for the neighborly bears," suggesting proper food storage is essential, especially with children present.
Bathroom considerations: Toilet facilities vary widely between sites, from pit toilets to complete absence. At Hall Island State Forest, "There's not much to them, no facilities or running water," requiring family planning for bathroom needs.
Tips from RVers
Power limitations: Most primitive sites near Croghan provide no hookups, requiring self-sufficient power solutions. The primitive sites at Della Terra offer "solar power to provide you with your electrical needs" according to Ashley F., making it somewhat unique among the region's primitive camping options.
Road access challenges: Several campgrounds have limited vehicle access. One camper at North Lake Reservoir Campground advises, "Make sure to take a left at the start of the lake, the right is all private road and you will have to turn around."
Supply planning: Limited services require advance preparation. A camper at Winona Forest CCC Camp notes, "There is a dollar general about 15 minutes away if you need some supplies," while Hall Island State Forest campers can find "the local convenience store, which offers shower facilities and bathrooms for a fee."
