Tent camping near Kirkville, New York provides access to several state forests with primitive camping options at elevations ranging from 1,200 to 1,800 feet above sea level. The region features mixed northern hardwood forests with beech, maple, and hemlock trees creating natural barriers between campsites. Most primitive campsites in the area can be accessed from May through October, though some remain open year-round with limited winter maintenance.
What to do
Fishing opportunities: At Hall Island State Forest, primitive campsites border the Salmon River Reservoir. "The draw for my friends and I at the time was a jump off the nearby Redfield bridge and swim in the Salmon River. Was also popular for fishing enthusiasts," notes reviewer Rachel P.
Kayaking access: At Bear Wallow Pond Dispersed Campsite, campers can paddle on a small pond. "I have been there in both summer, when the shoreline wildflowers are riotous, and in fall when the changing leaves are breathtaking. If you camp here, you can kayak or fish on the pond," reports Janet R.
Trail connections: Many primitive camping areas connect to regional trail networks. At Pharsalia Y Pond, campers can access "day hikes on the Finger Lakes Trail" and explore "several other ponds in the Wildlife Management area for good birdwatching," according to Janet R.
What campers like
Privacy between sites: Campers appreciate the natural separation at many primitive sites. At Morgan Hill Forest—Onondaga Trailhead campground, "this location is peaceful and quiet with mature trees and plenty of distance between neighboring campers, and would be an ideal setting for a group campout," writes Janet R.
Accessible fishing: Many sites offer direct water access. Thomas E. notes that at Hall Island State Forest, there are "fire ring set up a view of the water and for enable body person just a short walk up the path."
Wildlife encounters: The natural settings provide opportunities for wildlife viewing. At Spruce Pond Camping Area, one camper observed that "the animals at the pond are very active and made a lot of noise in the night," showing the close connection to nature at these sites.
What you should know
Permit requirements: Some Wildlife Management Areas require advance planning. At Pharsalia Y Pond, "camping in this DEC Wildlife Management Area campsite is limited, and requires a permit. Visit the regional DEC office at 1285 Fisher Ave., Cortland NY or call 607-753-3095... allow one week for permit to be processed."
Limited facilities: Most sites lack amenities. At Nature Lover's Paradise, tent sites include "access to a vast network of trails in upstate New York," but campers should come prepared for basic accommodations.
Seasonal conditions: Facilities change with seasons. Neil L. notes that at Spruce Pond, the "toilet isn't set up yet but will once the season opens."
Tips for camping with families
Choose accessible sites: Some primitive areas offer more family-friendly options. Pharsalia Y Pond "would be a nice family friendly weekend destination, as well as a great stop for through hikers," with "several fire rings and good tent sites as well as a gentle water access right on the shore."
Consider noise levels: Wildlife can impact sleep. One Spruce Pond camper mentioned that "this was a nice spot, but the animals at the pond are very active and made a lot of noise in the night."
Look for dual access sites: Sites with multiple access options provide flexibility for families. Bear Wallow Pond "is adjacent to a small parking area and fishing access on a really beautiful pond" allowing for both drive-up convenience and nature immersion.
Tips from RVers
Site selection for smaller rigs: At Morgan Hill Forest—Onondaga Trailhead campground, "there are two lovely developed campsites with parking spot right next to a cement pad with picnic tables and fire pits," making them suitable for small RVs despite being primitive.
Access considerations: Forest roads can be challenging. At Stoneys Pineville Campground, the "friendly hosts" can provide guidance on accessing appropriate sites for your vehicle size.
Water and dump station availability: Most primitive sites lack services. For those needing facilities, Cross Lake Park Campgrounds offers fifty-amp hookups and is a drive-in tent camping option with more amenities than forest sites.
