Tent campsites near Carthage, New York offer alternatives beyond the better-known state forests. The Tug Hill region's elevation ranges from 1,200 to 2,000 feet, creating microclimates that affect camping conditions throughout the year. Winter camping opportunities extend well into April due to the area's position in one of New York's heaviest snowfall zones, with some locations receiving over 200 inches annually.
What to do
Fishing opportunities: Stoneys Pineville Campground provides direct access to salmon fishing. "We have been out three is consecutively for salmon fishing and I have had a great time," reports one camper who found it "a great place to stay."
Water recreation: The tent sites around Carthage connect to multiple water bodies. At Alger Island Adirondack Preserve, access requires paddling since "the state park allows only car top boats." One visitor notes, "We kayaked all of our gear out to the island," making this a true water-based adventure.
Winter sports: During colder months, Winona Forest transforms into a snow sports destination. The area serves as "a hub for several snow mobile, cross country ski, and snow shoe trails," with visitors coming "to enjoy the last bit of the snow" even in early spring.
What campers like
Solitude: The boat-access requirement at Mary Island State Park Campground creates natural isolation. "Every site is far away from the next and each has its own unique and beautiful view of the water and surrounding islands," making it a top pick for privacy seekers.
Water views: Campers frequently mention the scenic waterfront locations. At Cedar Island State Park Campground, "Be sure to take in the sunrise/set while there," as one visitor recommends, noting the site is "really memorable due to it being on an island within the 1000 Islands."
Affordability: Many primitive campsites near Carthage are free or low-cost. Winona State Forest offers free camping with minimal amenities, making it accessible for budget-conscious campers who don't mind trading conveniences for savings.
What you should know
Access challenges: Many of the best tent campsites near Carthage require specialized transportation. For Cedar Island State Park, "You need a boat to get here, making it one of our favorite places to camp in NY," according to one camper who advises, "Don't think about it, just book this site."
Variable campsite identification: Finding designated camping areas can be challenging. At Winona State Forest, "The primitive campsite was a little difficult to find there's a tiny black and yellow placard that shows you where you can camp."
Weather considerations: Tug Hill's location creates unique weather patterns. Even in spring, campers report challenging conditions, as one visitor to Winona Forest CCC Camp noted: "I checked out primitive site on my own early in April it was cold snowing and raining. It didn't take away from the campsite at all though."
Tips for camping with families
Safety preparations: When camping with children at water-access sites, bring extra dry bags. At Alger Island, one family reported: "A lot of our stuff got wet due to big waves from boats crashing into our kayaks," suggesting families need waterproofing for essential gear.
Space requirements: Hall Island State Forest offers ample room for family setups with "enough space to set up a few tents of kitchen whatever else you really wanted," making it suitable for larger groups.
Wildlife awareness: At some locations, local wildlife may become persistent visitors. One camper at Alger Island warned: "don't feed the ducks. They will never leave," suggesting families should prepare children for appropriate wildlife interaction.
Tips from RVers
Limited RV options: Most primitive camping areas near Carthage aren't suitable for RVs. However, Winona Forest CCC Camp can accommodate small recreational vehicles. "I took my small RV here on its maiden voyage... I pulled to the back and parked out of the way," reports one camper.
Self-sufficiency required: RV campers must bring all necessities. "If you camp here, you need to be self sufficient as there is no running water or electricity. There is a dollar general about 15 minutes away if you need some supplies."
Seasonal considerations: Snow and rain can make access difficult for larger vehicles. While tent campers might manage spring conditions, RV campers should consider timing their visits for drier periods when forest roads are more navigable.
