Tent campers visiting Black River, New York can access several primitive camping options throughout the surrounding state forests. The camping season generally runs May through September at established locations, while primitive sites may remain open year-round depending on conditions. Winter camping opportunities exist at select locations for those prepared for cold weather conditions.
What to do
Paddle the waterways: Francis Lake offers excellent kayaking opportunities with direct water access from tent sites. According to Elizabeth B., the lake is "totally gorgeous, perfectly clean, and quiet" with "two access points to the water," including a hidden point where "a little stream turns under a few footbridges and out to Francis lake."
Fish the Salmon River: Stoneys Pineville Campground provides river access for fishing enthusiasts. Visitor Eric F. mentioned, "We have been out three is consecutively for salmon fishing and I have had a great time what a great place to stay." Another camper noted it's a "great site for fishing" with "friendly hosts."
Winter recreation: The state forests transform into winter sports hubs when snow falls. At Winona Forest CCC Camp, camper Quade S. described it as "a hub for several snow mobile, cross country ski, and snow shoe trails" where "several folks visited on Saturday and Sunday to enjoy the last bit of the snow."
What campers like
Boat-access only sites: Cedar Island State Park Campground requires water transportation to reach. Justin S. explains, "You need a boat to get here, making it one of our favorite places to camp in NY. There are quite a few sites here, all pretty private, but still make reservations." Another visitor, Harry H., found it "really memorable due to it being on an island within the 1000 Islands."
Youth camping programs: Adirondack Mennonite Camping Associates Inc offers structured camping experiences. Elizabeth B. describes it as "a classic summer youth sleep-away camp on Beaver Lake. Sleeping in cabins with bunk beds, swimming, canoes, and a high ropes course, gathering around the campfire to end the day- Beaver Camp has it all."
Small, quiet sites: Many campers appreciate the solitude of primitive sites. Kevin C. notes that in Winona State Forest, "The campsite was just feet off of Bargy Road. The only amenity was a fire ring made of rocks," yet "the campsite was quiet and peaceful" despite rain during his stay.
What you should know
Site identification challenges: Some primitive campsites can be difficult to locate. Thomas E. mentioned that at Winona State Forest, "The primitive campsite was a little difficult to find there's a tiny black and yellow placard that shows you where you can camp."
Limited facilities: Most primitive sites provide minimal amenities. At Mary Island State Park Campground, Matt L. notes, "You can only get to it by boat" and "Every site is far away from the next and each has its own unique and beautiful view of the water and surrounding islands."
Self-sufficiency required: Campers must bring essential supplies. Quade S. advises that at Winona Forest CCC Camp, "If you camp here, you need to be self sufficient as there is no running water or electricity. There is a dollar general about 15 minutes away if you need some supplies."
Tips for camping with families
Platform tent options: For families wanting a more structured experience, consider Adirondack Mennonite Camping Associates. According to Elizabeth B., "Weekend and week long programming for youth and families, or site rental of cabins and platform tents is available, as well as day use access to the beach and high ropes course."
Multiple tent capacity: Some sites accommodate larger family groups. At Francis Lake, Elizabeth B. notes there's "Room for two or three tents, two fire circles and has an outhouse. Great for swimming, kayaking, and a gorgeous place to wake up next to the water."
Check noise levels: Not all campgrounds maintain quiet hours. Michael B. cautions that at Canoe Point State Park Campground, some visitors "didn't sleep until almost daybreak...it was loud, foul language the entire time" which can be challenging for families with children.
Tips from RVers
Limited RV sites: Small RVs can access some primitive areas, but options are limited. Quade S. reports, "I took my small RV here on its maiden voyage. I found this spot on Google maps just pouring over imagery. I took off after work on Friday evening and pulled in after dark."
Supply planning: RVers should prepare for limited services. At Winona Forest CCC Camp, Quade S. advises, "There are 3 large buildings, a parking lot up front and a gravel driveway. I pulled to the back and parked out of the way. There was also an outhouse and a porta-potty here."
Accessibility concerns: Not all areas labeled for camping accommodate RVs. Michael B. warns that despite the name, Canoe Point has limited access options, explaining, "Everyone else who came were in basically large party-boats with multiple rooms for sleeping, though they set up tents."
