Tent camping near Sherman, New York offers primitive to semi-developed sites across state forests and private lands. The region sits within the northern section of the Allegheny Plateau, with elevations ranging from 1,300 to 1,800 feet. Weather patterns can shift rapidly due to the proximity to Lake Erie, creating localized weather conditions that differ from regional forecasts.
What to do
Hiking at Hector Falls: Near Forestry Road Dispersed sites, visitors can access this natural feature via a 2-mile trail. "It's a nice little 2 mile hike. Some good exploring. Bring tick/bug spray. Found several on my boys and me," notes a camper at Forestry Road Dispersed Campsite.
Wildlife observation: The forested areas provide opportunities for spotting local fauna. "The forest is enchanting," reports one visitor at Forestry Road Dispersed sites, while another camper mentions: "There's black bears that live in the several caves in the area... The bears are skittish, but they will find you if there's food in you camp!"
Paddling: Water activities are popular in the warmer months. At Private Island w/ Paddle Moor Co., visitors appreciate the boat access: "Having the availability to paddle right up to the island after you are done with your trip is also convenient."
What campers like
Seclusion: Many sites offer privacy not commonly found in the eastern states. "Quiet except for the distant rumble of a train passing the town down in the valley," writes a reviewer about Forestry Road Dispersed camping.
Budget-friendly options: Free camping is available at some locations. "If you don't mind roughing it a bit, it's really quite nice. Sites are first come first serve," notes a camper at Forestry Road Dispersed Campsite.
Unique camping experiences: Specialty sites provide memorable stays. One camper at Big Oak Hill describes: "It is a newly created campsite that is located on top of a hill with a big oak tree. The campsite is accessible by drive-in, but you may need a 4-wheel drive vehicle if there has been rain."
What you should know
Variable site conditions: Primitive sites often show inconsistent maintenance. At Warner Road Dispersed Camping, a visitor notes: "Kind of a gross site, the previous people who stayed at our site were messy and left litter, but it served its purpose as a free place to sleep along a longer trip."
Access challenges: Some locations require specific vehicles or navigation skills. A visitor to Big Oak Hill mentions needing "a 4-wheel drive vehicle if there has been rain," while a Forestry Road Dispersed camper shares: "Sometimes I read other people's reviews, and I just don't understand how we went to the same spot. This place is fine. Easy enough to find."
Regulatory confusion: Check current rules before camping. One Warner Road visitor cautions: "Like the other review, this site has a lot of litter. Clearly people are camping here at times but there are posted signs that say Day Use Only. It was quiet and dark."
Tips for camping with families
Safety precautions: Wildlife encounters require preparation. "There's black bears that live in the several caves in the area... Definitely be sure to pack up all food and trash at night," advises a Forestry Road camper.
Night sky viewing: Areas with limited light pollution offer stargazing opportunities. At Private Island w/ Paddle Moor Co., a camper describes: "When it was dark (pitch black) you could see all the fireflies. To be honest that was like a show in itself and made it also worth every penny of how beautiful it was."
Service availability: Cell coverage varies by location. "There is spotty cell service through the forest, usually you can walk around for a couple minutes and find some. I managed to get an average of 3-4 bars of 5g every day," reports a Forestry Road camper.
Tips from RVers
Size limitations: Many primitive sites accommodate smaller rigs only. At Forestry Road Dispersed camping, a reviewer with a 25-foot travel trailer reports: "I found numerous spots on SF-160. It rains a lot so keep your slip-ons near the door."
Weather preparation: The region experiences frequent precipitation. The same Forestry Road camper continues: "I would give this a 5 star if it didn't rain so much," and advises keeping footwear accessible due to muddy conditions.
Supply planning: Services are limited but accessible. "Howe's ace hardware is about 10 miles away with a dollar general across the street," notes an RVer at Streamside Eriegrove, providing information about where to obtain supplies when camping in this more remote area.
