My first time camping trip in a few decades... So can't compare to others (yet).

My campsite was 34W, right next the reservoir. Nice location however the website said it was full shade. The picnic table was in shade. The spot for the RV was full sun.

Pros:

Reasonable cost from NJ state website. I paid $41 for 2 days.

Campsites well spaced apart.

Staff friendly.

Boats/Kayaks can be rented.

Cons:

Showers were cold water only and very cold at that.

Late at night you can hear the drone of a major highway.