Busy but not quite a tourist trap
This whole area is lovely with a lot of serious hiking opportunities. The Natural Bridge is worth seeing, even if you’ve been to Utah etc., and there are different access options (trails, ski lift) to suit your whole family. Pros: many park activities (hiking, rock climbing, zip line), local activities (restaurants nearby, more hiking, fishing), shady campsites, large campsites, different options for staying over (lodge, cabins, RV, tents), picnic sites throughout, fire pits at camp sites, shower house, clean, kept up nice, lots of staff. Cons: crowded, busy, definitely need to reserve in summer.